Book Wars
E-books, eReaders, ebooks, e-readers … while the jury may still be out on spelling, there’s no denying that electronic books and readers are one of the biggest trends happening in 2011.
I bought my wife a Kobo™ for Christmas and she loves it, but being more of a traditionalist, I temper my enthusiasm for new technology with a certain amount of kicking and screaming.

While I know there is some debate as to whether e-books will replace traditional printed books, I think it’s important to remember that it doesn’t have to be an “either/or” decision. Each medium has its own benefits and practicalities. Let’s look at the following five criteria to see how they compare:
1.) Common Format
The electronic book market is currently in a format war, with the Kindle (Amazon), Kobo™ (Borders) and NOOK™ (Barnes & Noble) all battling for supremacy. Who will win is anybody’s guess, but the printed paper/bound cover format gets points for longevity.
2.) Overall Reading Experience
E-books offer a vast array of features to enhance the reading experience. For example, if you are a card-carrying member of the “American Bifocal Wearers’ Society” such as I, you can enlarge the text size to whatever size is easiest for you to read.
Some higher end models such as the Nook™ offer a lending feature, allowing owners to lend their favorite e-books to family or friends.
On the other hand, a printed book is more tactile allowing the reader to engage their sense of touch as well as sight.
3.) Safety
Drop a book and it’s safe. Drop an electronic reader and … well, you’ve got a 50/50 chance.
4.) Archival Storage
Paper has definitely proven the test of time (Dead Sea Scrolls anyone?) The typical lifespan of a high-tech device is somewhere in the neighborhood of 2-5 years. However, since e-books are still in their infancy, this one is hard to call at the moment. Check back with me in 2-5 years.
5.) Ownership
Once you purchase a printed book, it’s yours to keep. When you buy an electronic book, you are technically just licensing it from the publisher who could potentially take it away (rare, but at least one case has been documented).
So there you have it. I leave it to the readers (be it acoustic or electric) to choose the medium that best suits them.

Like
